Artmink

Shared Report

Share:

LinkedIn icon facebook icon X (formerly Twitter) icon

Rachel : Silver

Rachel Presents

Premium upgrade: Rachel delivers your appraisal as a guided podium narration with synced visuals and voiceover. Output is a narrated, animated slideshow with video intro and outro, sandwiching the autoplay voiceover sequence in actual video.

Rachel visual aid image
Battle Early Silver Age Comic Books Issues 57, 60, 62 Atlas Comics
Original Presentation Script

This auction presents a collection of three early Silver Age comic books: Battle issues 57, 60, and 62, published by Atlas Comics in 1958 and 1959. These raw, ungraded comics exhibit moderate age-related wear, including creasing and tanning, making them an accessible addition for collectors of pre-Marvel war anthologies. Professional, fast, and affordable in-house shipping is available for all items, ensuring a smooth purchasing experience.

Used for this report's TTS and avatar presentation.

Item Listing

Battle Early Silver Age Comic Books Issues 57, 60, 62 Atlas Comics

Source Listing: View original listing

Merge Reports: Yes (reconciled). Approval remains manual.

By: Atlas Comics (predecessor to Marvel Comics)

Style: Comics

Origin: United States

Materials: Paper

Age: 1958-1959 (Early Silver Age)

Condition: Good to Very Good condition with visible age-related wear, including creasing, edge wear, and tanning.

Value: $50 - $150

Peer-Reviewed Market Values

Dating Range
Pending structured dating
Auction Liquidation
Pending structured market values
Fair Market Value
Pending structured market values
Replacement Value
Pending structured market values
Comparables Used
No saved comparables yet
Research Confidence
Insufficient Data

Peer review completed, but this run did not return structured market value ranges.

Maker's Marks / Writing: Covers marked 'BATTLE', 'IND.', and bear the Comics Code Authority stamp.

Date: 2026-08-25 21:20:34.778186

Description:

Professional, fast, and affordable in house shipping available for all items. For higher resolution images please visit bid.craftedauctions.com Battle E{ellipsis}

Assessment:

This lot features a selection of three early Silver Age war comic books from Atlas Comics (the predecessor to Marvel Comics): Battle issues #57 (April 1958), #60 (October 1958), and #62 (February 1959). These raw comics showcase the gritty war anthology stories popular during the era and exhibit moderate wear consistent with their age.

Individual Images:

  • Imported listing images

Provenance:

Unknown

Condition:

Good to Very Good condition with visible age-related wear, including creasing, edge wear, and tanning.

Image Memory Note

Imported catalog activation record.

Keywords

['comic books', 'Silver Age', 'Atlas Comics', 'Marvel Comics', 'Battle', 'war comics']

The report was edited after initial Artmink draft. Original AI draft preserved in Artmink audit history.

Peer Review Summary

Dating Range 1958-1959 (Early Silver Age)
Auction Liquidation Pending structured market values
Fair Market Value Pending structured market values
Replacement Value Pending structured market values
Archived Matches No archive matches yet
Research Confidence Insufficient Data

Peer Review

Key Visible Evidence

The provided images display three raw, ungraded issues of 'BATTLE' comic books: issue 60 (October), issue 62 (February), and issue 57 (April). The covers show a 10-cent price, the Comics Code Authority stamp, and visible wear including edge chipping, corner rounding, creasing, and back-cover tanning, which directly contradicts the report's claim of 'Excellent condition.'

Market and Source Support

Comic book reference databases confirm these are issues of Battle, a war anthology series published by Atlas Comics (the 1950s predecessor to Marvel Comics). Issue #57 dates to April 1958, #60 to October 1958, and #62 to February 1959, aligning with the early Silver Age attribution.

Needs Verification

['A precise numerical grade (e.g., on the 10-point CGC scale) cannot be assigned without a complete page-by-page physical inspection.', 'Interior completeness, staple rust, and page suppleness remain unverified from exterior photos alone.']

Audit Conclusion

The report's identification of the titles, publisher, and era is supported by visible evidence and grounded sources. However, the condition assessment is significantly overstated and must be downgraded to reflect the visible moderate-to-heavy wear.

Report ID:  : g2n98s

Comparables (Similar Items)

No archived comparables matched this report yet.